ADVTA X EVIL

 A

In Advaita Vedanta, the concepts of moral evil and natural evil are understood through the lens of non-duality and the illusion of separateness. Since Advaita Vedanta teaches that Brahman (the ultimate reality or universal consciousness) is non-dual and beyond all dualities, it provides a unique perspective on these concepts that differs from more conventional theological or philosophical views.

1. Moral Evil (Actions of the Individual)

In Advaita Vedanta, the concept of evil in terms of human actions (moral evil) is tied to ignorance (avidya) of one's true nature. The self (Atman) is ultimately the same as Brahman, and all of creation is one undivided consciousness. However, due to the veil of ignorance (Maya), individuals perceive themselves as separate, distinct entities, which leads to attachment, desire, selfishness, and ultimately harmful actions.

• Ignorance as the Root Cause: According to Advaita, moral evil arises because of the ignorance of one's true self. People mistakenly identify with their ego or body (the jiva) rather than recognizing their essential nature as Brahman. This ignorance creates desires and attachments that lead to actions that harm others and the self.

• Karma and the Law of Action: Even though Advaita acknowledges the concept of karma (the law of cause and effect), it teaches that actions are the result of ignorance. In the illusory world of duality, actions are driven by the individual's false identification with the ego. Thus, the moral evil seen in the world is part of the play of Maya (illusion), and ultimately, it doesn't have any real existence because it is within the realm of appearances.

• Liberation from Moral Evil: The key to overcoming moral evil is the realization of one's true identity as Brahman. Once a person recognizes their non-dual nature, the impulse for selfishness and harmful actions naturally dissolves, and they act from a place of compassion, awareness, and selflessness. Thus, the ultimate resolution of moral evil is spiritual awakening and self-realization.

  Example from the teachings of Advaita:

  • Nisargadatta Maharaj, an Advaita teacher, emphasized that what we consider to be evil is the result of the mind's ignorance. In truth, there is no evil in the absolute, because all dualities dissolve when one realizes their true nature as consciousness.

2. Natural Evil (Suffering in Nature)

Advaita Vedanta views natural evil (such as natural disasters, disease, and suffering caused by nature) similarly to how it views moral evil—as an aspect of the illusory world of duality (Maya). In Advaita, the perception of suffering in nature is part of the impermanent world and is ultimately not real in the absolute sense.

• Maya and the Illusion of Separation: The natural world and its apparent suffering (such as natural disasters, illness, etc.) are perceived due to the veil of Maya, which makes the world of forms and phenomena seem real. In the absolute sense, everything is Brahman, and suffering and pain are part of the universal play of the divine. The perception of suffering in nature is thus seen as an illusion created by our limited perception.

• Suffering as Part of the Cosmic Play (Lila): In Advaita Vedanta, the universe and all of its phenomena, including suffering, are often described as part of Lila—the divine play. Since the world is an expression of the divine, all experiences, including suffering, can be seen as manifestations of the unfolding of consciousness. However, this does not mean that suffering is trivialized; rather, it highlights the paradoxical nature of Maya—where suffering appears real in the world of appearances but is ultimately transcended by the realization of non-duality.

• The Role of the Individual in Suffering: While Advaita Vedanta does not deny the experience of suffering, it teaches that the way one experiences and reacts to suffering is influenced by their ignorance of their true nature. For example, a person who sees themselves as separate from the world may react to suffering with fear, resistance, or anger. However, one who realizes their oneness with Brahman sees suffering as transient and ultimately not separate from the divine order.

  Example from Advaita Teachings:

  • Ramana Maharshi, a renowned Advaita teacher, often spoke about suffering in the context of self-inquiry. He emphasized that true suffering is caused by the identification with the body and mind. By inquiring into the self (Who am I?), one begins to see that the body and mind are transient, and the true nature of the self is beyond suffering.

3. The Relationship Between Moral and Natural Evil

In the non-dual worldview of Advaita Vedanta, both moral evil and natural evil are ultimately seen as aspects of the same illusion (Maya). They are phenomena that arise within the dualistic world of appearances but have no ultimate reality. The real challenge is not to try to solve evil through external means but to realize one's true nature as Brahman, which is beyond good and evil, pain and pleasure, life and death.

• Non-Dual View of Good and Evil: In Advaita, good and evil are relative concepts within the world of duality. The absolute truth, Brahman, is beyond such distinctions. Both moral evil (human actions) and natural evil (suffering in nature) are seen as temporary and illusory experiences that arise due to our misperception of the true nature of reality.

Summary:

• Moral Evil: It is caused by ignorance (avidya) and the false identification of the self with the ego. The key to overcoming moral evil is self-realization—recognizing one's true nature as Brahman.

• Natural Evil: Suffering in the natural world is an aspect of Maya and is ultimately not real in the absolute sense. Suffering can be transcended through the realization of one's non-dual nature.

In Advaita Vedanta, both moral and natural evil are ultimately illusory and dissolve when one attains self-realization. The true self, being Brahman, is beyond the dualities of good and evil, suffering and pleasure, and is eternally free from the limitations of the physical world.

A