A
Ah! You’re asking for a comparison between scientism (objectified, external, measurable knowledge) and Advaita (subjective, inward, experiential knowledge). Let’s break this down carefully, step by step, so the contrast is clear:
1. Ontology – What is Real?
| Aspect | Scientism | Advaita Vedanta |
|---|---|---|
| Core claim | Reality exists objectively, independent of observation. Matter, energy, laws of nature are primary. | Ultimate reality (Brahman) is non-dual; the world (Maya) is transient and relative. The self (Atman) and Brahman are one. |
| Method of validation | Empirical observation, experimentation, reproducibility. | Direct inner experience, self-inquiry, meditation, and realization. |
Summary: Scientism “objectifies” everything; Advaita “subjectifies” ultimate reality—it’s about the inner experience, not just measurable phenomena.
2. Epistemology – How Do We Know?
| Aspect | Scientism | Advaita |
|---|---|---|
| Source of knowledge | Sense perception, instruments, logic, peer verification. | Intuition, introspection, meditation, self-realization (Anubhava). |
| Certainty | Probabilistic, tentative, always revisable. | Experiential, immediate, self-evident once realized. |
Summary: Science is external and analytical; Advaita is internal and experiential.
3. Nature of Self
| Aspect | Scientism | Advaita |
|---|---|---|
| Self | Human consciousness is an emergent property of the brain. | True Self (Atman) is infinite, unchanging, and identical with Brahman. |
| Identity | Individual, limited, body-mind based. | Universal, limitless, beyond body-mind. |
4. Ethics and Purpose
| Aspect | Scientism | Advaita |
|---|---|---|
| Ethical framework | Often derived externally (laws, social contracts, utilitarianism). | Self-realization leads to spontaneous ethical living (Dharma) and compassion. |
| Purpose of life | Often pragmatic: survival, knowledge, progress. | Liberation (Moksha) from ignorance and the cycle of suffering. |
5. Metaphysical Orientation
Scientism: Objectivist; reality exists “out there,” independent of the observer.
Advaita: Subjectivist/non-dualist; reality is fundamentally consciousness, and the observer and observed are one.
Key Contrasts in a Nutshell
Object vs Subject: Scientism → external world; Advaita → internal consciousness.
Knowledge: Scientism → measured, repeatable, provisional; Advaita → direct, unmediated, absolute.
Self: Scientism → individual, brain-based; Advaita → universal, eternal.
Purpose: Scientism → progress/utility; Advaita → liberation/realization.
If you want, I can also visualize this contrast as a single diagram showing “Objectify → Scientism” on one side and “Subjectify → Advaita” on the other, which makes the distinctions very immediate and intuitive. It ends up looking almost like a philosophical map of reality.
Do you want me to make that diagram?
No comments:
Post a Comment