A
The mirror test is a method used to assess an animal's ability for self-recognition, which is often interpreted as a sign of self-awareness. It was originally developed by psychologist Gordon Gallup Jr. in 1970 for use with chimpanzees. The basic idea is simple: an animal is marked with a non-odor, visually detectable mark in a place it cannot see without a mirror (like the forehead), and then exposed to a mirror. If the animal investigates or touches the mark on its own body while looking in the mirror, this is taken as evidence that it recognizes the reflection as itself.
Mirror Test and Invertebrates:
When it comes to fish and ants, the mirror test has yielded intriguing and controversial results.
🐟 Mirror Test in Fish
-
Species: Cleaner wrasse (Labroides dimidiatus)
-
Findings: A 2019 study published in PLoS Biology suggested that cleaner wrasse could pass a modified version of the mirror test.
-
Fish with marks attempted to scrape their bodies against surfaces after seeing themselves in a mirror.
-
Control fish (no mirror or no mark) did not exhibit this behavior.
-
-
Interpretation: Authors argued this could indicate some form of self-recognition or at least self-referencing.
-
Criticism: Some scientists argue the behavior may not be true self-awareness but rather a learned association or social reaction.
🐜 Mirror Test in Ants
-
Species: Carpenter ants (Camponotus spp.)
-
Findings: A 2015 study from researchers at the French National Centre for Scientific Research suggested that ants may show self-recognition-like behavior.
-
Ants marked with a blue dot on their head and exposed to a mirror tried to clean it off.
-
Ants without a mirror or with clear paint didn’t do this.
-
-
Interpretation: Authors argued this was suggestive of self-recognition.
-
Criticism: Many researchers remain skeptical, as the cognitive mechanisms in ants are vastly different from those in vertebrates. The behavior might be more about responding to abnormal tactile/visual stimuli than genuine self-awareness.
Summary:
-
Fish and ants may show behaviors consistent with mirror self-recognition, but the scientific community is divided on whether this constitutes true self-awareness.
-
Debate continues about whether the mirror test is a valid indicator of consciousness across vastly different taxa (e.g., mammals vs. insects).
Would you like a comparison chart of how different animals perform in the mirror test?
A
There is no heaven, no afterlife etc. It's simply a concept created to erase the fear of death. It has no basis in reality whatsoever.
A
"Who powers the eye to see, the ear to hear, the mind to think? The Kena Upanishad reveals it is not the senses themselves, but Brahman—the unseen force behind perception, the eternal consciousness that animates all experience."
A
Summary Bullet (Quote Style):
"Free from dualities, the wise see beyond pleasure and pain, success and failure—resting in the stillness of the Self, untouched by opposites."
Would you like this expressed in a specific philosophical or scriptural context (e.g., Bhagavad Gita, Advaita Vedanta)?
a
No comments:
Post a Comment