A
Here’s an updated SBQ (Science-Based Question) addressing whether pomegranate can reduce TMAO risk from egg consumption:
🔬 SBQ – Can Pomegranate Reduce TMAO Production from Eating Eggs?
Question:
Do polyphenols in pomegranate reduce gut microbial conversion of dietary choline (from eggs) into TMAO, potentially lowering cardiovascular risk?
✅ Answer – Promising, but Not Yet Proven for Eggs
1. Eggs & TMAO Production
-
Eggs are rich in choline, which is metabolized by gut bacteria into trimethylamine (TMA) and then converted by the liver into TMAO—a compound linked to cardiovascular disease risk (pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov, mdpi.com).
-
One study found that ≥2 eggs in a meal increased plasma and urine TMAO (∼14% of total choline converted) (pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov).
-
However, effects vary between individuals, and additional research is needed to confirm long-term health implications .
2. Pomegranate Polyphenols Inhibit TMA/TMAO Pathways
-
A pomegranate polyphenol extract significantly suppressed microbial conversion of L-carnitine to TMA in lab tests (resolve.cambridge.org).
-
In vitro results also showed reduced TMA production from choline, suggesting a broad inhibitory effect (mdpi.com).
-
Controlled human trials are underway to test this: Quadram Institute’s TESSA study is evaluating how pomegranate extract affects TMAO production following carnitine (and potentially choline) intake (trial.medpath.com).
3. Egg-Specific Data: Still Pending
-
No published human trials have yet tested pomegranate’s effect on egg-induced TMAO production.
-
But based on evidence that pomegranate reduces TMA from both choline and L-carnitine in vitro, there is plausible potential that it may also reduce TMAO from eggs—but this remains an unconfirmed hypothesis.
⚖️ Summary Table
| Component | Effect |
|---|---|
| Eggs | Increase TMAO (choline → TMA → TMAO) with individual variability (pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov, onlinelibrary.wiley.com) |
| Pomegranate | Inhibits microbial conversion of both L-carnitine and choline to TMA in vitro |
| Human trials | TESSA trial ongoing for carnitine; egg-focused trials not yet conducted |
🧠 Conclusion
-
Can pomegranate reduce TMAO from eggs?
Possibly, based on lab studies showing inhibition of choline-to-TMA conversion.
But definitive human evidence for eggs is not yet available. -
What’s next?
-
Results from the TESSA study on carnitine may suggest broader effects.
-
Future human clinical trials are needed to confirm effects against egg-induced TMAO.
-
A
No comments:
Post a Comment