Tuesday, 22 July 2025

Here’s a detailed overview of Dvedhāvitakka Sutta (MN 19)—sometimes rendered as “Dweda vitaka Sutta 19”—from the Majjhima Nikāya, known in English as the “Two Sorts of Thinking” discourse:





🧠 Summary




1. 

Two Categories of Thought



Before his Awakening, the Buddha, then still a Bodhisattva, deliberately divided his thoughts into two categories:


  • Unskillful (unwholesome): sensual desire (kāma-vītakka), ill will (vyāpāda-vītakka), and harmfulness (vihiṁsā-vītakka).
  • Skillful (wholesome): renunciation (nekkhamma-vītakka), non-ill will (avyāpāda-vītakka), and harmlessness (avihiṁsā-vītakka).  




2. 

Observing Unskillful Thoughts



When unskillful thoughts arise, the Buddha observed:


  • They lead to his own affliction, the affliction of others, or both.
  • They obstruct discernment, instigate vexation, and do not lead to Unbinding (Nibbāna).
  • On this basis, he simply abandoned, dispensed with, and wiped them out of existence  .




3. 

Cultivating Skillful Thoughts



Skillful thoughts, however, served as catalysts for spiritual growth:


  • They lead to no affliction—neither personal nor for others.
  • They foster discernment, promote calm, and lead to Unbinding.
  • Engaging in them overnight or longer carried no danger, except possible physical fatigue, which could disturb the mind. Thus the mind must be steadied and unified to maintain concentration  .




4. 

Outcome: Jhāna & Higher Knowledge



Sustained focus on skillful thinking allowed the Buddha to enter the four jhānas:


  • 1st jhāna: rapture & pleasure born of withdrawal
  • 2nd: rapture & pleasure from composure
  • 3rd: equanimity with pleasure
  • 4th: purity of equanimity & mindfulness, beyond pleasure and pain  



From this stable concentration, he attained recollection of past lives and knowledge of the passing away and reappearance of beings—important higher knowledges preceding full Awakening  .





🎧 Video Explanation



This concise YouTube talk provides a clear summary of the sutta, ideal if you’re looking for a quick, engaging walkthrough.





📚 Further Reading



  • Bhikkhu Thanissaro’s translation: Provides the full text used above  
  • SuttaCentral translations by Bhikkhu Sujato & Bhikkhu Bodhi: Alternate accessible renderings of the sutta  






✨ Reflection & Application



  • Practical takeaway: By recognizing harmful thoughts and skillfully letting them go, one cultivates inner clarity and calm—leading toward deeper states of meditation and awakening.
  • Encouragement: Recognize the guiding principle here—abandon the unwholesome, cultivate the wholesome—which lies at the heart of Buddhist mental training.



Would you like the full Pāli text, a verse-by-verse breakdown, or discussion on how this sutta relates to contemporary meditation practice?


No comments: